I've seen a lot of shit slung at Senator Levin -- and others -- today after his vote against increasing the government CAFE standards. All other issues aside, I need to speak up in defense of his vote. First, the senate vote:
WASHINGTON -- Auto companies and Michigan lawmakers were regrouping Friday in the wake of the approval Thursday of a Senate bill that raises corporate average fuel economy mandates by 40 percent by 2025.
Passage of the bill was a huge blow to Detroit's automakers, which had lobbied hard against the new rules. They had backed a compromise proposed by Michigan Sen. Carl Levin, D-Detroit, Mark Pryor, D-Ark., and Christopher Bond, R-Mo., among others, that would have raised CAFE mandates, but less dramatically than the Senate bill.
Nearly the entire Michigan congressional delegation met this morning for 45 minutes to discuss how to proceed in the wake of the loss.
"The bill would mean the death of Michigan," said U.S. Rep. Mike Rogers, D-Brighton. "We owe it to a lot of families who rely on the auto industry to get this right."
Added Rep. Bart Stupak, D-Menominee: "You think things are bad now in Michigan? You haven't seen anything yet if that bill became law."
Stupak and Rogers said automakers need to emphasize their advanced technology efforts and push for more assistance to make vehicles like the Chevy Volt a reality.
But Sen. Majority Leader Harry Reid used harsh language to say that senators didn't find automakers credible suggested auto companies "misrepresented the facts" at time.
"We don't believe you anymore,'" Reid said. "The answer is we've had enough. It's time the American automobile manufacturers join with the rest of the world in recognizing that people want to buy more fuel efficient cars."What exactly did the increase in the CAFE standards do? Automakers have to produce cars that meet the new recommended level of fuel efficiency *OR* they will pay stiff fines to the federal government. Does this ruling do anything to encourage the use of alternate fuels? No. Will Big Oil now make ethanol available at all gas stations across the country? No. Will increased CAFE standards reduce the use of fuel consumption? Not necessarily, and if you look at the track record of the effects of the CAFE standards, you'll see that actually just the opposite has taken place.
What will happen? Well, the future for the traditional "Big Three" has been looking bleak for some time, along with all those corporations that supply them. Do they now have to build more fuel efficient vehicles? No. Do any of the automakers have to build more fuel efficient vehicles? No. My home state of Michigan has been on life support during these dark Bush-Rovian years, and this is essentially pulling the plug.
What won't happen? Big oil won't lose a dime. Big oil won't see to it that alternate fuels that are less harmful to the environment are available to you.
I thought we were struggling to make changes that improved -- or at least did less -- harm to air quality? Senator Levin(and others) wanted to go after Big Oil, and save his home state. He did his job well, as well as he could.
-Diane
Cross posted at Michigan Liberal